LOWERING THE AGE OF CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY AS A TOOL TO COMBAT JUVENILE DELINQUENCY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51891/rease.v12i11.32268Keywords:
Age of criminal responsibility, Discernment, Juvenile offending, Comprehensive protection, Socio-educational measuresAbstract
The present study investigates whether discernment among adolescents aged sixteen to under eighteen justifies lowering the age of criminal responsibility and whether this change is supported as a means of preventing juvenile offending in Brazil. The study uses qualitative bibliographic and documentary research and a deductive approach. It examines the Federal Constitution, the Criminal Code, the Child and Adolescent Statute, the National Socio-Educational Assistance System Act, academic articles, and institutional information. Five issues structure the discussion: constitutional limits, adolescent discernment, social vulnerabilities, the assessment of age reduction, and the effectiveness of socio-educational measures. Understanding unlawfulness, psychosocial maturity, criminal responsibility, and preventive effectiveness are treated as distinct questions. Current legislation establishes an objective age threshold and provides for a separate accountability system, including deprivation of liberty under statutory conditions. The studies examined employ different research designs and do not establish that transferring adolescents to the ordinary criminal justice system would cause a reduction in crime. Recognizing adolescents' abilities does not independently resolve constitutional questions or determine criminal policy. The article concludes that discernment alone is insufficient to support the central hypothesis. State responses should be evaluated in terms of procedural safeguards, implementation conditions, victim protection, and measurable outcomes. Improving socio-educational assistance and developing comparable intervention evaluations are recommended without assuming that either the existing model or its replacement is effective.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
Categories
License
Atribuição CC BY