RETIREMENT AS A CAUSE OF LOSS OF PUBLIC OFFICE: A STUDY ON THE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF REMOVING TEACHERS FROM THE CIVIL SERVICE AFTER THE 2019 REFORM
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51891/rease.v12i11.32479Keywords:
Constitutional Amendment 103/2019, Vacancy, Teaching profession, Social security, Statutory bondAbstract
Introduction: Constitutional Amendment No. 103/2019 added paragraph 14 to article 37 of the Federal Constitution, under which a retirement granted using contribution time from a public position, job or function breaks the bond that generated that time, ending the traditional autonomy between the social security relationship and the employment relationship. Aim: To analyze the constitutionality of this rupture when applied to teachers, a category with differentiated constitutional treatment. Materials and Methods: Qualitative, dogmatic-legal research, using deductive, monographic and comparative-evolutionary methods, based on bibliographic and documentary research and on a critical analysis of the case law of the Federal Supreme Court (ADIs 1,721 and 1,770 and Topics 606 and 1,150). Results: Before the reform, the Court held that voluntary retirement did not by itself end the employment bond; after it, the Court applied paragraph 14 to public employees (Topic 606) and reaffirmed the vacancy provided by local law for civil servants retired under the General Social Security Regime (Topic 1,150). The precedents found do not specifically examine the teaching profession. Conclusion: The unrestricted application of paragraph 14 to teachers appears constitutionally questionable, as it disregards the social value of teaching work, the contributory nature of retirement and the protection of legitimate expectations, which calls for a specific debate on the teaching profession.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
Categories
License
Atribuição CC BY