JOINT CUSTODY AND THE PRINCIPLE OF THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILD: A JURISPRUDENTIAL ANALYSIS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51891/rease.v12i11.31996Keywords:
Joint custody, Best interest of the child, Jurisprudence, Law No, 13.058/2014, Integral protectionAbstract
This article analyzes how the Superior Court of Justice and the Courts of Justice of Paraná, São Paulo and the Federal District applied the best interest of the child principle in joint custody decisions involving children under 12 years old, from 2018 to 2023. The central problem investigates how courts resolve the tension between the legal rule of joint custody, provided for in art. 1.584, §2, of the Civil Code as amended by Law No. 13.058/2014, and the filtering by the best interest. The methodology consisted of an integrative literature review in the SCOPUS, JSTOR, STJ, TJPR, TJSP and TJDFT databases, with a protocol structured in PICO and a final sample of 6, 5 from the 2018-2023 period and 1 complementary from 2026. The results show three categories: C1 - substantive application that departs from the rule due to concrete risk, C2 - formal application that maintains the rule even with parental disagreement, and C3 - cases of normative tension. It was found that the STJ has settled that conflict does not exclude custody, requiring proof of unfitness, domestic violence with a protective measure or serious parental alienation. As a product, an orientative protocol is proposed with legislative amendment, creation of a psychosocial support center and mandatory establishment of a reference home and coexistence plan.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
Categories
License
Atribuição CC BY