EVIDENCE, PRECAUTIONARY MEASURES, AND PROSECUTION POLICY IN ENVIRONMENTAL CRIMES AGAINST REEFS: PROCEDURAL CHALLENGES IN ALAGOAS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.51891/rease.v12i11.32387Keywords:
APA Costa dos Corais, Extrajudicial proceedings, Environmental legislationAbstract
The reef ecosystems of the Costa dos Corais Environmental Protection Area in Alagoas are facing severe degradation due to anthropogenic pressures. This scenario of chronic stress leads to coral bleaching and the resulting coral die-off, threatening local marine biodiversity. In light of this, this study aimed to analyze which procedural instruments, specifically injunctions, the presentation of expert evidence, and out-of-court settlements are most effective in establishing legal liability and securing civil redress for the damage caused to the reefs of Alagoas. The research sought to test the hypothesis that the weakness of technical evidence, resulting from the absence or untimely provision of specialized expert testimony, combined with the inappropriate application of precautionary measures, limits the effectiveness of environmental criminal prosecution in the region. Methodologically, a qualitative, bibliographic, and documentary study was conducted through an analysis of the current legislative framework, the Management Plan for the aforementioned Conservation Unit, as well as related judicial and extrajudicial proceedings. The results indicated that, although the extrajudicial consensus-building mechanisms promoted by the Federal Public Prosecutor’s Office expedite the resolution of conflicts, there remains a weakness in technical and expert evidence and an underutilization of the Agreement on Non-Prosecution, confirming that procedural misalignment and the absence of post-damage reports mitigate the effectiveness of criminal protection and active ecological restoration of marine heritage.
Downloads
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
Categories
License
Atribuição CC BY